
Landing moments before
The Dark Knight is the trailer for another hotly anticipated superhero epic: Jack Snyder's
Watchmen (2009). Adapted from Alan Moore (
From Hell,
V for Vendetta) and Dave Gibbons' landmark 1986-7 graphic novel,
Watchmen was a revelation in the comics world, garnering an unprecedented level of critical praise and influencing countless comics since. It won a Hugo, a first (and last) for the form. It wove an uncommonly dense and literate story, deftly critiquing the genre it embodied with layers of metafiction, alternate history, and Freudian analysis.
Snyder is still unproven with a dense, character driven story like
Watchmen. After two decades of false starts with the likes of Terry Gilliam, Paul Greengrass, and Darren Aronofsky,
this guy finally gets the shot? Really? His remake of
Dawn of the Dead (2003) was exciting and technically competent, but lacked any of the social commentary or strong characterizations of George Romero's 1979 original. And
300 (2007), adapted from Frank Miller's graphic novel, was an exercise in pure style, an epic ode to testosterone that somehow managed to be both homoerotic and homophobic. (Kind of like pro wrestling.) These films boast attractive surfaces and visceral thrills, but little to linger in the mind afterward.
But the trailer gives me hope. Cut precisely to the Smashing Pumpkins track "The Beginning is the End is the Beginning," it looks simply amazing. (A neat reversal; it's a
remix of a song in
one of the worst comic book movies.) Working from a draft by
X-Men scribe David Hayter and Alex Tse, Snyder keeps in so many of the things that make
Watchmen special.
The scope, and fidelity to the source is simply staggering. Sharp-eyed viewers are rewarded with a number of astonishing details: Tricky Dick on TV, the brand of hairspray Rorschach wields, Dr. Manhattan's expression moments before becoming something more that human. The promise of the Vietnam and Mars scenes alone have me giddy with anticipation. (Physically,
Veidt looks a little off, however.)
The real worry is the way Warner Bros. is marketing this movie. This is not
Spider-Man or even
Batman Begins. These characters do not benefit from years in the public consciousness. These are introspective, dark, middle aged antiheroes in a $100 million dollar, political, R-rated, two-and-one-half-hour period piece spanning the 30's through the 80's set against the backdrop of the Cold War. I doubt any of the tween ticket buyers were a proverbial gleam in their fathers' eyes when the USSR rolled into (and out of) Afghanistan. The action beats of Moore's story are perfunctory, yet the trailer sells them hardest; the real conflicts are largely philosophical and emotional. Perhaps the topicality of the material (note the skyline behind the Owl Ship) in out post 9-11 will strike a cord with audiences.
If not, Zack Snyder might have the next great cult film on his hands.
Check out the trailer here.